Butt Creek, Indian Creek, Middle Fork Feather River, Yellow Creek

Plumas County Summer Stream Hopping

August can often be one of the warmest months in Northern California. The average temperature this time of the year usually ranges from the low 90s to triple digits making the heat miserable for both anglers and fish. This summer however has been a bit of an exception. The large snowpack that we received during the winter and spring has helped provide cooler water for fish giving anglers more time than previous years to purse their fishy friends.
I spent my last weekend in Plumas County, a recipient of this cool water blessing, and got into some of the best fishing I’ve had this time of summer in a long time.

Green Yellow Creek

My first destination would be Yellow Creek near Almanor. It’s been about three years since I last visited this beautiful spring creek and I was excited to see if there had been any improvement with the fishing. Although the meadow was looking a bit yellow it was also mid-summer so I wasn’t expecting verdant green fields this time of year. I settled for a spot a bit below the empty Yellow Creek campground and rigged up my 3WT.
A quick look into Yellow Creek made me rethink if driving to the creek was a good idea. There seem to be an awful lot of green algae settled in the bottom of the creek which I had never seen before. Spring creeks are suppose to be made up of the purest and cleanest water so why was there so much gunk everywhere.

Yellow Creek Rainbow Dry Eater

I started working my way around the creek and found a few small fish here and there. It was mid-afternoon so dry flies weren’t working too well. I switched to an indicator rig and began picking off fish. Most of the fish I spotted and caught where small however I did manage to sight one of the biggest fish I had ever seen in this creek near an undercut. It looked about +18” and spooked as soon as I noticed it. After catching few rainbows and a brookie I decided to move to a different stream. The fishing was just too slow for a few dinks, not fun.

Butt Creek

On the way out I stopped at Butt Creek. I’ve seen a few nice browns in this creek however I’ve only had luck catching dinky rainbows even smaller than those in Yellow Creek. I left after about an thirty minutes still yearning for better water and better fish.

Indian Creek Falls
Below Indian Creek Falls

As I made my way to Quincy I stopped and fished Indian Creek below the falls. This was my first time fishing Indian Creek and unfortunately it didn’t fish as good as it looked. I managed to land a small trout and a hardhead before calling it quits. I felt like Indian Creek had more of a population of rough fish than trout. Maybe things are different when the flows are bigger and cooler though. I may have to try it again next season before crossing it off my list.

Middle Fork Bow

I spent the night at my in-laws who live about ten minutes away from the Middle Fork of the Feather River. The MFFR usually runs a bit warm this time of year giving me doubts about how well it would fish however I couldn’t beat how close it was to the house.

I hiked into the canyon and found myself in a familiar place that I wish I returned to more often. The cool breeze as I stepped into the cool water felt nice and the river looked like it was in fantastic shape. The fishing was excellent. There were fish everywhere, in the riffles, runs, pools, tailouts, and even in the flats all eating dries, streamers, and nymphs. It was nice to hook into some quality MFFR fish instead of just dinks this weekend. These fish were wild bright red white tipped rainbows that only a wild and scenic river could produce. Now that is what I call fun.

Doesn’t Look Like It But This Fish Was +20”
Butt Creek

Trending Deeper Into Butt Creek

Butt Creek is a small stream located south of Lake Almanor that originates from Butt Mountain where it flows downstream to Butt Lake. I’ve visited this creek a few times before but never got the chance to truly explore it. The last time I visited the creek late last year I found some nice size brown trout that I was surprised to see in such a small stream. Excited about my discovery, I took the day to revisit and try to find these big brown beauties.

Butt Creekin’

Butt Creek shares similarities to many other volcanic creeks near Mount Lassen. Formed by mostly porous volcanic rock, this creek hosts many different species of aquatic insects. I found that there were three different distinct sections of Butt Creek: a meadow section, a valley section, and a canyon section. The first section I explore was the valley section off Humbug Road.

The valley section is the most accessible section of Butt Creek. Lined with willows and other native vegetation, this section is primarily composed of shallow riffles and runs with a few deep holes here and there. I caught a lot of small rainbow trout in this section that were quite interested in my hopper-dropper combo. From the most upstream bridge, I hiked downstream into the canyon section.

Butt Creek Bows

The canyon section began about two and a half miles downstream of where I started. There were a few diversion dams that kept showing up as I worked my way down the sloped canyon. These dams were great spots to fish since they all created nice big pools. I rose a few bigger fish but wasn’t able to set the hook on any of them. All of the fish I caught were rainbows.

First Diversion Dam

I hiked further downstream and arrived at the famous Butt Lake powerhouse. Through the use of a large tunnel, water is diverted from Lake Almanor to Butt Lake where it reaches the powerhouse and generates electricity. Pond smelt that inhabit Lake Almanor are often ejected from the tunnel to Butt Lake where they become disorientated and fall prey to large browns and rainbows.

The powerhouse was running during my visit and there were plenty of pond smelt around however I didn’t know the secret to catching fish in his spot. I tried stripping and dead-drifting streamers but wasn’t able to entice any bites. My guess is to either fish early or late when the fish are feeding and use shiny minnow patterns. I will definitely return to this spot someday to try and figure it out.

Butt Lake Powerhouse
Butt Lake Pond Smelt

After a tiring hike back to my car I drove up to the meadow section. I was hoping that the water here would be deeper but it was the shallowest section that I explored this day. There were still fish around but they were all tiny rainbows. I quickly gave in and called it a day.

I’ve concluded that Butt Creek is definitely a small stream fishery and although I didn’t find any brown trout it was neat to explore new waters. If your in the area I would suggest fishing Yellow Creek over Butt Creek since they are relatively close to each other. You just can’t beat spring creek fly fishing.

Fish Of The Day
1 2