Oahu

Fly Fishing Oahu: The Bonefish Blues

Bonefish are one of the most prized and sought after saltwater fish that fly angler’s target. They are notorious for cruising shallow flats, rocketing off as soon as they are hooked, and only taking flies that are presented properly.
During my time in Oahu I was finally able to meet these fish in person and see what all the buzz was about.

The best way I can describe a bonefish is if a carp and a steelhead had a baby and that baby lived in the ocean. Bonefish feed on prey that live near the bottom much like carp in freshwater and are easily seen on the flats once your eyes have been trained what to look for. Bonefish are like steelhead in that they are powerful swimmers and a good day is a fish or two at the end of your line.

I’ve heard and read that the bonefish on Hawaii are different from bonefish from other parts of the world. They are rarer, bigger, smarter, and harder to catch. These fish have been preyed on by humans for thousands of years and continue to be caught and eaten my the locals making them hyper wary of bait and flies. After trying my luck out on the flats myself I found everything about these Hawaiian bonefish to be true and more.

Hawaii’s Coral Flats and Mr. Pufferfish

The saltwater flats are unlike anything I’ve ever fished before. The flats of Oahu are made mostly of coral with deep sandy channels that will often split access to the next flat. I spent most of my time fishing the flats to the east of Diamond Head. The beaches of Hawaii are all public access however the best and easiest access to the flats were found throughout the various parks along the coastline. The flats were also quite void of fish which I was not expecting. The fishing would often be slow which made sighting other species on the flats more exciting than the bonefish themselves.
Out on the flats of Oahu you will find that mother nature has left you with very few friends. Your only friend on the flats will be the sun which will help you spot the slightly greenish glow of the fish as they cruise around. Clouds made sighting fish difficult but not impossible. Your other enemies will include the wind and coral all which are very prominent in Oahu.

Imagine casting at a good size trout that is cruising up and down a lake eating dries in shallow water. Now factor in 15+ MPH winds with 20+ MPH gusts. Good luck, have fun…
The amount of wind on the flats was insane. The heavy wind made sighting fish difficult as well as presenting the fly extremely challenging. A little too close and they’ll spook and a little too far and they won’t see it. I was unfortunate to only fish windy days throughout my trip which made the fishing quite frustrating.

Windy Flats

The coral was another bane of the Oahu flats. There were several ways to present your flies to these fish however I found that the presentation that got the most attention were long slow strips. Too slow and you’ll snag on the coral, too fast and the fish will spook. The coral literally snags everything. I can’t tell you how many times I would get a fish to follow only to have my fly get caught in the coral.

Honolulu Airport Flats

After hooking two bonefish on my own that broke me off I wanted to spend more time exploring the island with my wife. Instead of spending more hours trying to chase unicorns I hired a guide from Fly Fishing Hawaii. Not only did my guide Makani have a cool name, he was also a cool dude. If you want to fish with a local Hawaiian fly fishing guide that knows his stuff Makani is definitely your guy. Makani took me out on his boat to where I believe was the best spot to target bonefish. These flats next to the airport were amazing and full of fish. Although the fishing conditions were very far from ideal: heavy winds, mostly cloudy, and fishing off a full moon, we managed to get a two grabs from a bonefish and land three species that I can add to my “have caught” collection. Sometimes the off catches can be more exciting, fun, and memorable than the targeted species. I highly recommend Makani’s fly fishing service.

I Couldn’t ID This Fish
My Second Trumpet Fish
Hawaii’s State Fish The Humuhumunukunukuāpuaʻa

Throughout my trip I managed to hook four bonefish that broke me off as soon as I stripped set. I spotted more than enough fish and had plenty of chances to present my fly however the elemental factors were just too much for me and I was not destined to land any this time around. I did however manage to catch several different saltwater species that I was happy to have at the end of my fly line. All-in-all Oahu is a tough place to bonefish, I’m glad I live in California.

Snagged A Little Lizard Fish
Nice Blue Trevally
Butt Lake, Hex, Middle Fork Feather River

Butt Lake Hex & Middle Fork of the Feather River

Butt Lake

I’ve read and heard that the hex hatch happens on Butt Lake about two weeks before it starts on Lake Almanor. Prior to heading out I checked to see if there was an updated fishing report on the area from Lake Almanor Fly Fishing and to my surprise the report read that the hex hatch was beginning to happen. This would probably be my only chance this year to fish the hex hatch so I decided to give it a shot despite not exactly know what I’d find.

There are a few things that make me favor the hex hatch on Butt Lake versus Lake Almanor and tranquility is one of them. The most inconvenient aspect of fishing Butt Lake’s hex hatch is the long dirt road to get to the dam where the hatch happens. The road is well-maintained however it is made of red clay dirt which gets everything dirty. There is also no official launch site which means you’re going to have to carry your floating device down to the lake.

I arrived at the lake around 6:30pm and started fishing shortly after setting up all my gear. I noticed a few hex shucks in the water but not a whole lot. I used a Teeny 200 sink tip line that got the job done the last time however I wasn’t able to hook any fish before the hex hatch started.

The hatch started at around 8:45pm after sunset. It was a very poor hatch that lasted about three minutes; I probably saw a total of twenty duns. The fish that were targeting the hex where only eating dries and they stopped soon after I was able to switch between my rods. The lack of hatch activity was possibly due to the cooler weather that day and the timing of the hatch. After the waddle of shame back to the car I contemplated on where I would spend my next fishing day.

MFFR Nelson Creek Access

Middle Fork Feather River
Although I wanted to explore and fish Butt Lake below the powerhouse generator I decided not to due to the drive. I instead decided to visit one of my favorite places that was within a ten minute drive, The Middle Fork of the Feather River.

I consider June on the Middle Fork to be the best month to fish it. The run-off is over and the water hasn’t gotten too warm yet. I fished the Nelson Creek access and the fishing was excellent. The hot fly that the fish seemed to be keyed in on was the prince nymph. Every fish I caught nymphing was on this particular pattern.

Fish of the Day
Prince Eater

I’ve come to know the fish on the Middle Fork as aggressive wild trout. These fish will attack a streamer with no mercy therefore I always make sure to bring a versileader so that I can strip some streamers. I was not disappointed with my choice.

Lil Streamer Eater

I also explored Nelson Creek a bit further upstream. I’ve read that Nelson Creek can hold fish up to 16” however I find this hard to believe. There seems to be a point in the creek where it becomes fishless despite all the beautiful runs and pools. My theory is that the creek blows out often during the run-off making it difficult for trout to inhabit therefore the fish that are found in the creek reside close to where the creek meets the Middle Fork of the Feather.

The Middle Fork of the Feather is an amazing fishery that seems to have changed very little despite the high water floods. The fish are all wild and you definitely have to work to find the good ones. I wish I could have spent more time on the river but I had to all to myself while I was there and what could be better than that.

Beautiful Middle Fork
1 24 25 26 27 28 150