Horseshoe Lake, Paradise Lake

Paradise Lake & Horseshoe Lake, The Hate and Love

Lil Paradise Gill

One of the great aspects of fly fishing is the concept of learning how to be successful. To me, taking the time to learn a body of water and figuring out the puzzle of what works and what doesn’t is far more rewarding than catching a few here and there. There is one lake I tell people I “hate” because it is by far one of the most difficult still-waters I’ve fished so far.I hate Paradise Lake. 
When I use to fish with a spinning rod it was pretty easy and on most days I ended up catching more than a few bass, but once I picked up my fly rod the entire game changed. This Sunday I fished Paradise Lake to see if I could finally figure it all out.

Paradise Lake
On Sunday the weather was still a bit cold. The cold front had finally begun to taper to an end but the clouds and winds were still around. I found the water to be relatively warm and there was a lot of nice tall grass growth on the banks; ideal holding spots for bass and other fish. The lake had been stocked with trout a few weeks ago and the majority of anglers were targeting the planters. However, I had different intentions.

Paradise Lake is known for its quality largemouth bass population however, the conditions that they live in make them wary and smart. The clear blue waters with a visibility of 5ft or more makes these bass difficult to target, especially if fishing from the bank. They’ll see you before you see them and tricking them into eating a fly is futile if they saw you throw it.

I tried different sink-tips, patterns both big and small, and various retrieves but nothing proved successful. The only fish that were willing to bite were the tiny bluegills. I did manage to hook into an 18”+ bass but on its first jump it threw the hook. Pretty awesome to see it all happen though.

I definitely need to take the time to learn how be successful on Paradise Lake. The next time I get out there I’ll try fishing bluegill
patterns, maybe that will motivate the bass enough to get them to take. I hate Paradise Lake because its challenging, but love it because that’s what makes it fun.

Horseshoe Lake
Horseshoe Lake is my still-water success story. This small “lake” is the complete opposite of Paradise Lake. The clear blue waters are muddy and turbid and foothill forest is a tall grassy meadow. Countless trips of trial and error is how I learned to be successful on this particular body of water.

Another Bobber Cat

I spent an evening during the week to fish the lake and caught a dink catfish. My standard rig wasn’t working so I switched and quickly found success. I also snagged myself another bobber fish but it was a dink that was somehow able able to break itself off. At least I was able to release this one.

I’m tired of catching dinks. This Memorial Day weekend will be a great fishing weekend and I’m ready to catch some trophies.

Tied me a Trophy catching fly
Big Chico Creek

What’s In The Big Chico Creek Upper Watershed

Upper Big Chico Creek

Finding new waters to adventure, explore, and fish are some of my favorite aspects about fly fishing. I find myself spending hours on Google maps looking at a body of water I haven’t fished yet to strategize access points, gear needed, walking distance, etc. Once I figure out the logistics, I look online for clues on what flies work, what kind of water I’m fishing, and what species I may find there. After doing my homework I set out to explore more of Big Chico Creek.

The fish I wanted to find and catch were brown trout. I have read several articles about brown trout being present in the upper watershed of Big Chico Creek. Brown trout are suppose to be the dominant fish in mountainous zone.

Big Chico Creek at Carpenter Ridge Road

The day began with what I thought was going to be a nice drive down to the creek on Carpenter Ridge Road but instead it turned into an hour hike. The hike wasn’t difficult (thank god…) and once I got to the water I was relieved. One thing I noticed immediately was the geography of the creek not being very freestoney; this was a bad sign. Wading about half a mile upstream, I didn’t get a single fish despite fishing nice seams and pools. Although there weren’t any fish in this stretch, I did find a lot of California newts.

Saw a ton of these guys

After not having much luck, I started to feel discouraged. On the hike back to my car I was contemplating on what to do for the rest of the day. Should I float tube Tiechert or Pine Creek? Should I fish Horseshoe or go back to the Sac for shad? Once I got back to the car it was decided, “What the hell… I might as well try the creek further upstream.”

Oh The Places You’ll See

The drive up HWY 32 was short and once I set foot into the water I had a good feeling about this area. The water was more freestone but very small only about 4 – 6ft wide. This was the “don’t try back casting or you’ll hang up on everything” type of small stream.

First of the Day

After finding a decent riffle, I threw my dry into a seam and got my first rise of the day. Bingo! This was the place to be. My adventure to find a BCC brown trout continued as I waded about a mile upstream catching a few decent-sized fish along the way. Surrounded by tall green pines and clear cool water, it’s almost hard to believe that this is the same Big Chico Creek that runs through Chico.

And yes the studies and articles are true…

Big Chico Creek Brown
1 112 113 114 115 116 150